Beldaran wrote:I'm not an idiot because I refuse to pay again for something I already own.I think a graphical update would be really fun! I'd like to see a 3D engine power the game, but with the exact same viewing perspective. Fresh new graphics, updated sound, and the music done by a full symphony/rock band.
It would be incredible, people would piss themselves and basically put indiscriminate wads of cash in envelopes and mail it to Square.
If you don't want to rebuy the game, that is perfectly fine with me. The problem I have is with people who feel they are "being ripped off" because it's a port and not a complete remake ala FFIV DS. What I said over at Kotaku - seriously, if you don't like it, you don't have to buy it! I'm interested in it purely because it's the first real handheld version of the game (and no Mott, I'm not going to go through the effort to stick a ROM of it on my DS :P)
Personally I don't see a need for them to change the graphics. The graphics of Chrono Trigger were already gorgeous. Would I complain if they wanted to do that? No, of course not. But I see no need to complain that they are *not* doing it. It's not like this is an NES title or something.
But the main thing is, why should Square put forth that effort? I mean, on a game that already exists? If they are going to put that much effort into it, I'd rather they just do a damn Chrono Trigger 3 instead, you know? I get the feeling that some people (esp. the people over in those Kotaku stories) get this idea in their head that Square can just flip a switch and magically update all the graphics (one guy said they should be as detailed as The World Ends With You as his example.. seriously?). It just doesn't work that way. Particularly when they want to reuse the old game engine.
Anyways, I agree with mrz84 regardless on this, the DS is not the best place for a "3d update". I mean, FFIII DS and FFIV DS are both nifty and all, but the "3d update" looks like crap. It's basically N64 quality graphics. Personally, what I'd like to see is a console release - and honestly I'm aiming more at another sequel when I say this. Look at some of the more recent Dragon Warrior games. They used cel-shaded 3d artwork that resembled Akira Toriyama's "Dragonball Z style" art. How awesome would that be for Chrono Trigger? Rather than the very bland style Chrono Cross used, go with fully cel-shaded DBZ style art to match the SNES title.
Oh, and regarding the new dungeon - maybe. But remember, there is also that robot Collesium thingy in the future that was cut. I would love to see them add that back in, even if it's not a full dungeon but maybe something like FFVI's collesium (just not auto battles :P). They could even tie the new "Wifi multiplayer" battle mode into it. I would love to see Singing Mountain too, but from what I saw of the maps, it didn't look all that interesting. Just kind of another pre-historic mountain region. I'd like whatever they chose to add to be visually interesting (which I suppose the Dragon Cave in FFVI Advance was kind of ugly too, but at least it had a few varried areas)