I don't mind the musicians voicing their opinions, but sometimes it detracts from the music. Take the Beastie Boys' recent album, "To the 5 Boroughs". The album definitely does not approach the levels of Paul's Boutique or Hello Nasty, but it loses even more through its politically charged rhymes.
It wouldn't be so bad if the rhymes weren't so weak, but they also cover every cliche attack against the Bush administration that even the staunchest of Democrats has abandoned.
The result is 5 years from now the songs will no longer be culturally relevant and no one will care about them. I'm still listening and singing to Hello Nasty, but I don't think I'll ever sing wack rhymes like
"Because George W got nothing on me\We got to take the power from he"
"We got a president that we didn't elect\The Kyoto treaty he decided to neglect"
Good job guys, I'm sure you'll free Tibet if you keep churning out fresh rhymes like that.
On the other hand, Outkast did a far better job of expressing their opinion in the song War from the recent album "The Love Below\Speakerboxxx". Rather than spreading their opinions across the entire album, they decided to leave it in one song so as not to alienate their pro-Bush listeners. Instead of whining about the election, Big Boi explores the causes and comes up with some nice points:
"Politicians, modern day magicians
Physicians of death, more health care for poor health
Who makin us ill, they makin us kill
That's makin me spill my guts (chill Big, lay in the cut)
For what? I refuse to sit in the backseat and get handled
Like I do nuttin all day but sit around watch the Cartoon Channel
I rap about, the Presidential election and the scandal
that followed, and we all watched the nation, as it swallowed
and chalked it up, basically America you got DUCKS
The media shucked and jived now we stuck"
Imagine that, instead of taking the knee-jerk response, he blames not only the politicians but the media and the sheep that are influenced by it. After continuing with more well-stated commentary on the state of America, Big Boi rightfully makes his declaration of mental superiority:
"I'ma always bring food for thought to the table in the kitchen\Now eat nigga"
The Beastie Boys protest Bush. Outkast protests Bush, the state of America, and the state of the people that brought it to here. The Beastie Boys blame one man for America's troubles. Outkast professes that several factors (Bush as one of them) combined to bring us to our current state.
The result is the Beastie Boys remind me of System of A Down by using cliched comments that have been force-fed since Bush was elected, while Outkast makes me sit back and evaluate my beliefs. It's as if the Beastie Boys were a man holding a sign with a 2-word slogan outside the voting booth and Outkast is the man who writes an article for a magazine analyzing the candidates. Both are valid expressions of opinion, but one is more effective.